Skip to Main Content

It’s a running joke that no matter what symptoms you plug into WebMD, cancer is one of the possible diagnoses. So I was pleasantly surprised when cancer wasn’t high on the list in a search I did. But it should have been.

I had turned to WebMD because of a lump in my throat. On a visit to see my family in Kansas City, Mo., my mother noticed it. She mentioned she had been diagnosed with an overactive thyroid gland (hyperthyroidism) in her 20s.


I brushed it off as nothing, especially since I didn’t have any of the typical symptoms of an overactive thyroid — no weight or hair loss, no sweating or insomnia. Even my old Kansas City doctor thought the lump was nothing when I visited him to refill a prescription that had run out.

Back home in New York, things began to change. My clothes became loose even though I was eating like my stomach was a bottomless pit. My thick mane of hair started thinning out and clumps of hair began clogging the shower drain. My heart pounded as if I was running a marathon, even while sitting. And though I was always tired, I had trouble sleeping no matter how exhausted I felt.

I made an appointment with my primary care physician. But I also did what many people do before they see the doctor — plugged my new symptoms into WebMD. I didn’t include the lump in my throat because it didn’t seem to be related to anything, and my old doctor hadn’t seemed worried about it. WebMD suggested that I had hyperthyroidism and 98 other possible conditions. Cancer didn’t appear until far down the list; thyroid cancer wasn’t on it at all.


My doctor agreed that I probably had hyperthyroidism. We joked about the Adam’s apple-sized lump in my throat while she drew blood to check my level of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH). A low level indicates hyperthyroidism.

Curiously, my TSH level was completely normal. My doctor quickly referred me for a neck ultrasound and thyroid biopsy. I also had blood tests for everything from tuberculosis to lupus and Rocky Mountain spotted fever to find what was causing my symptoms. All of the tests came back negative, except the neck ultrasound and biopsy.

At 5 p.m. on a Friday, my doctor called and told me I had thyroid cancer. I didn’t hear anything she said after that, much like Walter White in “Breaking Bad.” All I really cared about at that moment was getting a cherry soda, as if the sugary drink would magically undo what she had said.

While the news that I had follicular thyroid carcinoma at age 23 caught me completely off guard, I was thankful that I was deemed “cured” after a simple surgery.

Luckily, the answer I got on WebMD didn’t seriously delay my diagnosis or harm my health. But it did change my thinking on these self-diagnostic tools. If I’m genuinely concerned about a new problem concerning my health, I now schedule an appointment with my doctor instead of paying a visit to WebMD. After the appointment, I use various websites, such as WebMD and the Mayo Clinic, to find information about the diagnosis, tests, or medication side effects.

The day may come when computers can accurately diagnose illness from a collection of symptoms. Until then, I’ll be sticking with medically trained humans.

Amy S. Wheeler is a senior account executive at Tiberend Strategic Advisors, a corporate communications firm specializing in the health care and life sciences industry. She also codirects Cupid’s Undie Run — New York, a charity run and party for the Children’s Tumor Foundation, a nonprofit dedicated to ending neurofibromatosis through research.

  • Have you tried checking also with YouShield app? Comparing with WebMD it usually provides more precise health problem descriptions.. However, cancer is usually on the list as well:)))

  • That thyroid biopsy is the best thing to do when there may be a problem with your thyroid gland. My primary care doctor first did an ultrasound and scheduled me with an appointment with an endocrinologist. He did a needle biopsy not long after the ultrasound. Now I go in every other year for an ultrasound (I have a goiter on my thyroid) and have blood tests annually. It’s good to keep up on things, and getting the most information you can regarding what may be your medical problem is always a good idea. WebMD is OK, but going to special disease specific medical sites can also be helpful. When I had a desmoplastic melanoma, about which no one could give me much information, I found several sites to get more knowledge about what was surgically removed.

  • Hi, Amy. Just for your sake, I’d like to point out that WebMD isn’t a failure, it just doesn’t have the ability to x-ray you. You should always schedule your doctor’s appointments, but don’t be afraid to see what WebMD has to say before you go to your appointment. ☺

    • Agree. WebMD actually saved my life. I had symptoms of a pulmonary embolism, but no one thought there was any way I could have one, even the ER docs. My mom also reassured me that I definitely didn’t have one, and she was a nurse who worked with a lot of patients who had them. I just couldn’t shake it so went to my PCP one more time and explained my symptoms again and she referred me for a CT scan. Turns out I had DOZENS of pulmonary embolisms and a large infarct on my lower right lung. If I hadn’t read Web MD, I would’ve just believed everyone and not worried about anything. I would likely not be here today if I had continued to ignore my symptoms.

Comments are closed.