s the abuse of prescription painkillers stubbornly persists across the country, nearly half of the states have attempted to cut off the supply at its source in the past year, by making it harder for doctors to prescribe the addictive pills to Medicaid patients.

States such as New York, Rhode Island, and Maine adopted new limits on the number of pills that doctors can prescribe, and West Virginia will, starting next year, require prior authorization from the state’s Medicaid program for opioid painkiller prescriptions. In the 2016 fiscal year, 22 states either adopted or toughened their prescription size limits, and 18 did so with prior authorization.

The goal is to make physicians think twice before prescribing the highly addictive medicines — a change many say is necessary, especially within the state-federal health insurance program for low-income people. Research indicates that Medicaid beneficiaries are prescribed opioids at twice the rate of the rest of the population, and are at three-to-six times greater risk of a fatal overdose.


The rules can take the form of seemingly straightforward controls such as limiting prescriptions to a one-month supply and requiring patients to pick up their doctors’ written re-fill order in person. For some physicians and patient advocacy groups, though, they are problematic.

“This is really going to limit patient access,” said Dr. John Meigs, president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, and a practicing doctor in Centreville, Ala. “There are patients with legitimate pain, who have legitimate need.”

Many states acted after the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services released a list of “best practices” last January, which encouraged state Medicaid programs to adopt more stringent requirements for opioids. Some states had already done so, but the CMS advisory accelerated the trend.

A total of 46 Medicaid programs have put in place prescription caps, 45 require prior authorization, 42 need proof that patients meet medical criteria to receive opioids, and 32 allow the drugs only after patients have exhausted other options, which is called step therapy.

Some commercial plans are also using these kinds of strategies, though experts said it’s unclear how far that trend will spread.

“This is an indication that policymakers are finally recognizing that overprescribing of opioids is fueling the epidemic,” said Dr. Andrew Kolodny, a Brandeis University senior scientist and the executive director of Physicians Responsible for Opioid Prescribing, an advocacy group. Both overdose deaths involving prescription opioids and US sales of the drugs have roughly quadrupled since 1999, with more than 14,000 deaths reported in 2014, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Others addicted to pain pills die after switching to opioids such as heroin and fentanyl, which often sell for less on the street and pack more of a punch.

But some physicians argue that this perspective overlooks the separate, underlying challenge of treating a chronic condition. “Just because it is now harder to prescribe patients opioid medicines, it does not mean we have fewer patients who have pain,” said Dr. Eric Weil, the associate chief for clinical affairs in internal general medicine at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

Such restrictions can become a difficulty, especially since Medicaid beneficiaries already are dealing with limited means.

For instance, a smaller prescription dose means patients who already are suffering intense pain, making travel a hardship, have to visit the doctor more often for medicine absorbing time and extra money for gas or public transportation.

Worried about creating such barriers, some state Medicaid officials are trying to strike a balance between limiting abuse and allowing reasonable access to medications.

Louisiana’s Medicaid program, for instance, has capped the number of pills a doctor can prescribe, so a prescription can’t span longer than 30 days, and it requires proof that clinical guidelines have been followed before opioid painkillers are used. State officials are eyeing additional changes, such as lower prescription caps and prior authorization for opioid prescriptions.

But years of budget cuts mean there’s not enough money to properly cover a robust array of alternatives to opioids. For example, beneficiaries are limited to one visit with a pain specialist.

“It’s not enough,” said SreyRam Kuy, Louisiana’s Medicaid medical director.

“We need much more to address this,” she said. “If you just cut off the pills, it’s not addressing the bigger picture.”

Massachusetts’s Medicaid program also has in place some of the prescribing controls. But it, too, is “pretty haphazard” when it comes to making alternatives available, Weil said.

That’s a real concern, said Dr. Steve Diaz, an emergency physician in Maine, who is consulting with that state’s Medicaid program as it develops its regulations. The patients being squeezed often don’t have extra money to pay out of pocket for options such as acupuncture and tai chi or yoga classes, all of which can sometimes be used to help manage pain, he noted.

That said, given the spread of opioid abuse, using insurance rules to curtail prescribing makes sense, he said. And while evidence is limited, restricting insurance coverage generally has worked to drive down prescriptions of other particular drugs. But “these are blunt instruments,” Diaz said. “We do have to be thoughtful.”

If Medicaid plans try to curb physician painkiller prescribing, they need to be nuanced, Kuy said. For instance, states must account for people such as cancer patients, who may legitimately need heavy-duty opioids. Carving out the right kinds of exceptions, Diaz said, will be a major challenge.

And, experts noted, it’s still unclear if these strategies can make a difference.

“Will these policies have the intended effects? There’s very limited evidence [they will],” said Dr. Jonathan Chen, an instructor at Stanford University School of Medicine, who has researched opioid abuse. “On the other hand, the problem has grown to the point where we have to do something.”

This story was published in partnership with Kaiser Health News.

Leave a Comment

Please enter your name.
Please enter a comment.

  • Because of this new law.. It has become so much harder on me , as I am on SS and medicaid. YES! BUT.. I do have CANCER, and several other problems. I have severe pain , yet because of this new law. My NURSE PRACTITIONER HAS DROPPED MY FENTANYL, and my break through pain killers. If she continues to drop them anymore, I will not have any quality of life and will live out the rest of my little bit of LIFE IN PAIN! THANK YOU FOR YOUR NEW GUIDELINES! This is totally ridicules, as I am 62 years old and have been on pain meds since I was 29 yrs old., for severe Arthritis, and now stage 4 CANCER..

    • Shelley,
      First, I’m sad that your stage 4 cancer and second not kept comfortable during this phase of the disease.
      There maybe laws however being kept comfortable for end of life care as the outcome is going to be the same is not in the best interest for the patient.
      I use words, keep the patient extra comfortable as their is a moral and ethical drive in end of life care.
      We don’t allow animals to suffer and we should not allowing a human patient either.
      Get in touch with your doctor that is managing your case! Ask that the outcome is going to be the same and that you want extra comfortable as your wish. It’s a moral and ethical obligation and there are UN laws showing that patients in pain and withholding care or opiates is considered human torture.
      I hope you or family are advocating for you and your pain management well.

  • A lot of people get pain medication that don’t need it and it makes it more difficult for the chronic pain suffering people who really do need it. That’s where some of the problem lies. These people who get it and don’t need it sell it to people who legitimately do but either don’t have a Dr or insurance and sell the medication at a ridiculous price like a dollar a milligram when the person selling the medication most likely has medicaid and likely only paid $3 for their script. If such a person gets 120 roxicodone 30 mg thats $3600 they’re making off that one months script. That’s what’s really hurting the people who have real pain and actually need the medication to try and lead a halfway normal less painful life

  • I have been taking my meds for awhile. I have chronic pain all over had several surgeries and still need to have some more done. They can’t seem to find what causing some issues.Some days i have to cry to get what i need done not to mention i have 2nd and 3rd degree burns. I have not one time asked for any increase or diffrent medication. With out them i couldn’t move. I have had injections in my back,knees,and ankle till they don’t help.

  • Why is it that the government is perfectly to legalize Marijuana, which destroys your lungs and causes cancer, yet they restrict opioids that are
    safer when used responsibly. I think that this the real issue is that the insurance companies are happy to not have to provide them so they save money.

  • I have been safely taking Vicodin for over 10 years. Because of these wonderful pills, I can exercize, ride my bike and swim with my kids.
    Without them this will be impossible. Now I am forced to pay for a doctor
    visit every single month! Soon they will take away my right to take these
    pills and take something much more harmful. That or move to another country.

  • I am a breast cancer survival, and had a tram flap. Because of the tram flap surgery, I have these sharp bolts poking me on my left side that developed over time. I can’t have surgery done on it because it is too close to my ribs…I can’t even explain the extreme pain I live in daily. I am now living in fear they will take my pain medicine, and I will have to live in that horrible pain again…The pharmacy CVS is always treating me like I’m a drug addict. And i take my medicine exactly as prescribed. I am also bipolar and suffer from anxiety and panic attacks. When I was 9 years old a Dr. put me on valiums because my anxiety was so bad I couldn’t talk. I have been on them for 40 years. Recently, A new mental health Dr. has taken away my valiums, I haven’t been able to leave the house for fear of talking, having a panic attack and I can’t eat or sleep.I also have IBS-C which is worse when your under stress. Why punish the people doing right over the people abusing there medication. I can’t believe they would take someone’s life and just end it like nothing!

    • Ms Fox,

      Your story is exactly the ones that need the voice of your own to be out there to CDC, DEA, DHS, US Congress, and any other local, district, county, state needs to be heard!
      Your DNA / Human Genome is different like everyone else and medicine is not an exact science. Just like no one person finger print is the same.
      Therefore, we can’t have “One Size Fits All” when in comes to medication management.
      The broad brush is hurting the responsible patients or humans that follow directions.
      Also, congratulations for kicking cancers ass!
      Anxiety comes in all different forms, triggers, DNA, and anxiety is historically a great thing to create change for some people. Change is messy kind of like removing the ground or dirt to pave the way for a new home, road, plants, survival, etc. This is not to discount your personal anxiety in any way.
      1) Get rid of CVS or on a receipt leave bad comments online and ask to speak to a manager. You are important and everyone matters. I personally look at name tags to those people that smile and help me without judgement. Then I praise them through their online surveys.
      2) Keep telling your success story as that is a moment of strength you can relate too! The next time you feel judge or sense it in any form, tell them I beat cancer and I’m coping with the injuries from that fight!
      3) Maybe you have done this or not, diet for IBS. Find your triggers. Were you eating something that didn’t agree with your IBS? Emotional trigger from what ever triggered your mind to anxiety to IBS. I’ve had some people just go vegan diet that cured the IBS and that is another challenge.
      You are a cancer survivor and you have great works to do and you tell anyone that judges you that you survived a horrible cancer and beat it, any questions?
      Thank you for expressing your story!!

  • Well I don’t mind it if VA would incorporate marijuana for medicinal purposes!!
    I have server nerve pain and spazing! T8 incomplete spinal cord injury! My pain level is so loud and tolerance so high it’s insane!!!! On Medicaid I can’t see the professional I need to see! Get down to the bottom of it! So Medicaid can you really look at if you’re going to take away the medication that people really really really do need to make it through the day pain free if it makes him a little groggy at least they’re pain free and then weed out the ones that are misusing the medicine bi monitoring the ones at home the ones living in a facility they are already monitored so why would you take away their medication?!? Well this ain’t going to solve the problem I’m only one voice

  • I have had 3 back surgerys knees are bad had 2 surgerys on left shoulder I need one done on it I hurt all the time but I take my meds the way I post to and they want to cut me down and I been taking them overs 20 years they up my pain and the state want to make people that do good suffer and the Addicts get what they want and it not right thank you

  • I have had 3 back surgerys knees are bad had 2 surgerys on left shoulder I need one done on it I hurt all the time but I take my Ned’s the way I post to and they want to cut me down and I been taking them overs 20 years they up my pain and the state want to make people that do good suffer and the Addicts get what they want and it not right thank you

  • 86 & chronic pain patient for over 10 years. Bad fall on stairs 3 years ago added to the chronic pain already going on. I had extra pain meds after surgery but took myself off of them back to maintaining dose.Fall tore rotator cuffs in both shoulders, tore biceps in one arm, cracked both wrists, broke a second hip, open forehead wound, etc. Those were added to other problems that took me to pain specialist. Have stayed with that treatment since then. I’m housebound, can’t go anywhere but to the doctor when he says I have to in order to get meds. At 86, we know I’m not going to get better. I can’t stand the thought of cutting down on pain meds I take. Am in bed most days, but will certainly be there more on days if government cuts down on my meds thinking it’s cutting down on addicts. Addicts will find a way to get more. All I can do is take what my doctor gives me. It’s not up to the government or any organizations to dictate meds on people. Doctors are trained to do this. If people abuse them, which I know is a fact, don’t punish the people who really need them.

Sign up for our Morning Rounds newsletter

Your daily dose of what’s new in health and medicine.

Privacy Policy