T

o encourage a Florida doctor to write more prescriptions of the potent painkiller Subsys, executives of the drug’s maker invited him to company headquarters near Phoenix and took him out for a night on the town, according to a federal indictment released Thursday.

Two top sales officials of Insys Therapeutics entertained the physician at a “club,” where they stayed until 4 a.m. “Went fantastic last night,” one of the company’s regional sales managers wrote in a text message to a sales rep, the indictment says. “He had to have had one of the best nights of his life.”

The next week, the doctor wrote 17 prescriptions for Subsys — a legal form of the opioid fentanyl — when he usually averaged about three. He also received $260,050 in payments over three years for participating in the Insys speaking program — something federal officials allege was nothing more than a mechanism for bribing doctors.

advertisement

Federal prosecutors in Boston allege the Florida doctor was one of several medical practitioners bribed by Insys employees as part of a national conspiracy to boost sales of Subsys. Six former Insys executives and sales managers were arrested Thursday in response to a 60-page indictment detailing allegations of bribery and kickbacks.

Insys said in a statement that it is cooperating with authorities and “committed to complying with laws and regulations.”

Subsys was launched in March 2012 into a crowded field of competitors, which included other brand-name medications and several generics. The drug was approved only for cancer patients with intense flares of pain — a narrow market — and only about 2,000 doctors in the country prescribed fentanyl products. The drug is also expensive, costing thousands of dollars a month.

The company, prosecutors allege, overcame these challenges with a speaker program — whose stated purpose was to educate doctors on the use of the drug — to bribe doctors. In an email titled “Live Speaker Targets,” former Insys chief executive Michael Babich wrote to sales managers to make certain sales reps understood “the important nature of having one of their top targets as a speaker. It can pay big dividends for them.” In a text message to a sales rep, former Insys vice president of sales Alec Burlakoff wrote that doctors “do not need to be good speakers, they need to write a lot of” Subsys prescriptions.

To sweeten the pot, the Insys employees allegedly scheduled speaking events at establishments owned by doctors, or their families and friends. The events allegedly had little do with education: They were often held at high-priced restaurants and attendees were frequently just friends of the doctor hired as the speaker, the indictment alleges. Fake names were used on sign-in sheets, and some events had no attendees at all, according to prosecutors.

The indictment does not identify by name any of the practitioners who allegedly received the bribes and kickbacks.

The company meticulously tracked results from the speaker program, calculating a ratio of return on investment for each speaker using metrics such as the number of prescriptions written by the speaker and the total amount the company paid the doctor. If doctors failed to boost their prescribing after being paid to be an Insys speaker, the company would reduce the number of their speaking engagements, according to the indictment.

In the case of an advanced practice nurse in Connecticut, the sales manager for that state became frustrated when the nurse failed to prescribe more Subsys after being paid as a speaker. “Very simply when I look at return on investment as she has not motivated any new prescriber as of yet and she is not significantly increasing her own business, I am going to have tremendous difficulty in justifying more programs,” the manager wrote. The nurse eventually increased her prescribing and received $78,748 in speaking fees from the company.

One doctor in Arkansas allegedly promised Insys sales reps “more scripts than we can handle” once he started to be paid as part of the company speakers program.

In 2012, Burlakoff traveled to Michigan to meet with a doctor who owned a Saginaw pain clinic with more than 5,000 patients. Insys wanted him to write more Subsys prescriptions. After taking the doctor to dinner, the indictment alleges Burlakoff sent an email to members of the sales team telling them “expect a nice ‘bump’ fellas.”

The Michigan doctor was enrolled in the speakers program, receiving payments totaling $138,435, and his prescribing of Subsys increased, according to the indictment. Doctors like the one in Michigan “keep us in business,” Burlakoff wrote. He added, “lets get a few more and the rest … of this job is a ‘joke.’”

An attorney for Burlakoff, George Vien of Boston, said his client would plead not guilty and “fight the case.” The other defendants or their lawyers couldn’t be immediately reached for comment.

The Insys sales force targeted the top prescribers of all fentanyl products, according to the indictment.

When Babich received a list of doctors in the Insys speaker program writing a large number of prescriptions for competitors’ drugs, he allegedly emailed Burlakoff. “I thought we owned the high decile folks?” he wrote. “Lots of big names on there.”

The sales force for Insys reaped large financial gains of their own if the doctors they called upon increased their prescribing. In some cases, sales reps were assigned just one doctor — usually a big prescriber.

In Alabama, a sales rep was told by a superior he could make an additional $40,000 over three months if the doctor he was assigned to wrote just two Subsys prescriptions a week during that time.

The indictment alleges the former Insys employees also targeted doctors known to have questionable prescribing practices. In one case, the target was a doctor in the Chicago area that an Insys sales rep wrote in an email “runs a very shady pill mill and only accepts cash.” The doctor was eventually paid over $70,000 for company speaking events.

Sign up to our Daily Recap newsletter

Please enter a valid email address.

The key to the success of Subsys, according to the indictment, was incentivizing doctors to prescribe the drug to patients beyond the limited market of cancer patients suffering from breakthrough pain.

At a 2014 national sales meeting, Burlakoff told the sales force the cancer market was “small potatoes. That’s nothing.”

While the alleged bribes resulted in doctors writing more prescriptions for the drug, insurance companies were still reluctant to pay for Subsys prescribed to patients who did not have cancer.

To fix that problem, Babich and others allegedly created an elaborate system to trick insurers into making payments for off-label uses of the drug. They created a call center at Insys headquarters to handle insurance reimbursement approvals for doctors prescribing Subsys. Employees in this unit allegedly contacted insurers, creating the appearance they were calling from the office of the doctor who wrote the prescription, and deceiving them about the patient’s diagnosis and medical history. They often added a diagnosis of dysphagia, which is difficulty in swallowing. This gave a product like Subsys, which is a nasal spray, a big advantage over similar products that were in pill form and had to be swallowed. Other times, the employees of this unit would falsely claim the patient had cancer, according to the indictment.

Employees of the unit were rewarded with lucrative financial bonuses if the entire unit met a weekly target of reimbursement approvals. The target was known as “The Gate.”

Leave a Comment

Please enter your name.
Please enter a comment.

  • I have been HIV positive for a decade 11-17-05 date of diagnosis. I did not have to start a pain medication regimen until 07/2012. My pain is located at my lower legs and feet. The only way I can explain the condition is my bones in my legs feel like they are blistering on the inside. Also uncontrollable flexing of my calves. Can wake me from a dead sleep. Extremely uncomfortable and slowly progressing up both legs. Now the arch in my right foot seems to be developing regular Charlie horses.
    I started the 800mcg dosage a year and a half ago. I will attest to anyone who wants to hear this medicine has changed my life for the better. I’m completely aware of the risk attached to all pain medications, insys the company that provides the medicine to me at no cost.
    So I have not paid one dollar for the medicine they provide for me. I could never do the things that I enjoy or need to do (walking is incredibly difficult until the first dose is administered in the morning). My quality of life has improved dramatically)
    In closing I would like to thank Insys for patients assistance program that I have been able to qualify for. Feel free to ask me anything about my experience with this company. The medicine is incredible to my quality of life

    Zachary Farmer

  • Excellent article…. I’ve been to dinners sponsored by drug companies, but never felt pressured to prescribe their drugs.

  • This is revolting, but isn’t it common pharma practice? I am one of the people who has had the money-or-your-life gun to my head for hep C cure when it was urgent. I have been looking into the whole filthy industry. I was lucky and rescued by the fixhepc buyers club- generics, look it up, or ask me, but this is what I found and it outrages me- not double, not ten times, but 19.1 expenditure on ‘marketing’ than R&D: http://www.medpagetoday.com/PublicHealthPolicy/HealthPolicy/34103

  • As a physician, I can personally attest to the fact that this influence peddling is pervasive. Drug sales reps are selected for and trained in influence. The big-ego clinicians to whom they peddle think themselves above such tactics but are really cattle to the slaughter.

    To preserve your integrity in the eyes of your patients, clinicians should NEVER meet with drug reps under any circumstances. Any organization that allows their employed clinicians to do so should be held suspect.

  • All kidding aside (previous comment) too bad Trump is the president-elect. I do not expect him to champion an investigation into pricing. It’s too bad one’s health continues to be dependent upon how much money they can afford for medications. Disgusting!

    • Oh contrarie, that comment was most certainly not meant in any manner to be in jest!

      You have a Congress so hog-tied to their own opioid-like dependancy re lobbyists and campaign funds that Big Pharma has free reign to price their congressionally mandated monopoly products at whatever the market will bear.

  • ….the best night of his life” ? There must have been female “escorts”. Wait, wait…does this company also make expensive drugs to treat STDs? Two for one here. Pretty clever!

Recommended Stories

Sign up for our
Daily Recap newsletter

A roundup of STAT’s top stories of the day in science and medicine — delivered straight to your inbox every weekday afternoon.