Herpes is a lifelong infection, but Lauren had it only for six tumultuous months. Or rather, she believed she did, after a request for sexually transmitted disease testing returned a positive result. But after weeks of Googling, chatting with members of online herpes forums, and reading scientific papers, she asked for a different test, which eventually confirmed her suspicion — her herpes diagnosis was wrong.

In the six months that passed between the tests, the mistake led her to keep a romance at bay and left her anxiously patrolling her health.“Every tingle I would get in my leg or any kind of itch down there would just set me off,” sending her into a new flurry of research, she said. “And that was just to try to calm my own anxiety, but it would only really make it worse.”

Genital herpes, predominantly caused by herpes simplex virus type 2, is a sexually transmitted disease that’s very common — 1 in 6 people aged 14 to 49 in the United States have HSV-2, and this number goes up with age. Most of these people, however, don’t have obvious symptoms and wouldn’t know they were carriers without blood tests.

But blood tests can be highly unreliable. The kind of test used to diagnose Lauren, an IgM test, has long been rejected by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention but is still used by some clinicians. Meanwhile, the CDC and the US Preventive Services Task Force concur that the most widely available herpes test, called HerpeSelect, should not be used to screen asymptomatic people because of its high risk of false positives: Up to 1 in 2 positive tests could be false, according to the USPSTF’s most recent guidelines.

That high failure rate isn’t, however, always communicated to patients. Online forums abound with stories like Lauren’s, of people who request herpes tests alongside those of other STDs and are shellshocked by the results. Some doctors discourage the testing or simply don’t include it in a standard STD panel without having the conversation. But no data exists on herpes screening rates, according to Kimberly Workowski, lead author of the CDC’s STD treatment guidelines — so it’s difficult to say how many people could be living with the misdiagnosis.

Herpes simplex
A micrograph of herpes simplex virus in a Tzanck test specimen. CDC

Testing pitfalls

Next to the meandering waterways connecting Puget Sound to Seattle’s Lake Washington is the only laboratory in the world that offers to the public the Western blot, the gold standard test for herpes. The University of Washington Clinical Virology Laboratory provides the test to patients across the country, a practice it began over a decade ago when it realized the more common tests were prone to false positives.

The problem, said Christine Johnston, a physician and researcher at the lab, is “low-positive” results of antibodies to HSV-2. The cutoff for a positive result on the HerpeSelect test, manufactured by Quest Diagnostics, is 1.1. A 2005 study published in the journal BioMed Central Infectious Disease found that index values above 3.5 yielded over 90 percent accuracy — but scores between 1.1 and 3.5 had around a 50 percent chance of being wrong.

What’s more, scores falling just above the 1.1 cutoff had an almost 90 percent chance of being wrong.

When tests fall between 1.1 and 3.5, more testing is necessary, said Johnston. This recommendation is also noted in the 2015 CDC Sexually Transmitted Diseases Treatment Guidelines. But some patients will never be referred for a second test.

“I think most clinicians are unaware and perhaps labs don’t have this available and/or it is not straightforward to order,” Johnston said of second-step tests.

But while her facility’s Western blot is considered highly accurate, it is expensive and cumbersome to perform. Each test costs over $200 and the University of Washington is the only lab that provides it.

Other confirmatory tests also exist, for instance Biokit’s HSV-2 Rapid Test and Quest’s own HSV-2 IgG Inhibition assay. The latter, which adds only $4 to the price of the HerpeSelect test, performed well in a study conducted over a decade ago. Rick Pesano, the medical director for infectious disease at Quest, believes that with more awareness, the test could stand in for the Western blot. But the test was not mentioned in the USPSTF guidelines because it still has not been evaluated in asymptomatic individuals, according to Cindy Feltner, associate director of the RTI-UNC Evidence-based Practice Center, who helped prepare the science review for USPSTF.

“We need better diagnostic testing. That is where we are stuck at this point,” said Johnston. “We don’t have a good test that’s inexpensive, high throughput, and reliable.”

Finding out the hard way

No good data exist on how often patients with questionable positive results are actually re-tested. Until the 2015 update, CDC herpes testing guidelines had no mention of confirmatory testing for low-positive results, said Johnston. So patients often discovered the option not through their doctors, but through searching the web and reading online herpes forums.

That was the experience of Bryan, a 40-year-old man who lives in Indiana, who wrongly believed he had herpes for about two months in 2011. The misunderstanding actually put him at higher risk, he said: During those months he considered joining the hundreds of thousands of Americans on dating sites for herpes-positive people. Exclusively dating people with herpes would have increased his likelihood of contracting the virus.


Sign up for our Morning Rounds newsletter

Please enter a valid email address.

The experience of YT, a 33-year-old mom who has suffered from frequent herpes symptoms over the last year, shows another side of the testing breakdown. She believes she was given HSV by a partner who didn’t realize herpes wasn’t included in his previous STD tests, she told STAT. Having herpes has caused her significant emotional trauma, and has driven her to permanently swear off dating. Had her partner known his true status, she wonders if her story would have been different.

These kinds of stories come out in anguished postings on internet forums and in dozens of confused calls to the UW lab each week, where research coordinator Matt Seymour says some desperate patients call over and over again, unable to get the answers they need from their doctors.

“People call and say, ‘I just don’t know what’s going on,’” he said. “We’ve almost become de facto counselors.”

Transmission electron microscope scan of cytomegalovirus particles. CDC

In the absence of answers

Herpes tests aren’t the only ones with a risk of false positive results. False positives can occur for any test that diagnoses viral infection based on antibodies, i.e., your body’s immune reaction, rather than direct detection of the virus. For similar diagnostics like HIV and hepatitis C testing, protocols automatically call for a second test that directly detects the virus whenever an antibody test comes back positive, said Paul Swenson, laboratory director in the department of public health of King County, Washington. Herpes, however, is a particularly challenging infection to directly test for, because the virus spends most of its time hiding in nerves. Swab tests can sometimes detect the virus during outbreaks, but this isn’t an option for people without symptoms. Thus even the Western blot relies on antibodies, and may give indeterminate results to a small number of people.

But two steps of antibody testing are still more reliable than one step; today’s diagnostics for Lyme disease and syphilis are a two-step antibody testing approach, said Dr. Edward Hook, a medical epidemiologist specializing in STI screening and prevention at the University of Alabama, Birmingham, who questioned why such a standardized two-step approach hasn’t taken firm hold for herpes.

“Some research has shown that two-step testing … might improve the specificity — that is avoid false positive results for the blood test — which would be a great thing because these diagnoses create great anxiety and concern for people,” he said. In a commentary accompanying the USPSTF guidelines, Hook expressed disappointment that herpes testing had barely improved over the past decade.

“There is no perfect test but there are ways to reduce the inaccuracies and reduce the number of equivocal results and those are actively used in other diseases,” he said in an interview with STAT. “But they haven’t been used very aggressively for the purpose of herpes.”

In the absence of sure-fire test advances, education and a lessening stigma surrounding herpes might help, not only by reducing test-related confusion, but potentially by bringing discussion of the virus out into the mainstream, said Hook.

“There’s no major herpes advocacy group,” he said. “People call attention to diseases that they suffer from, but people with herpes don’t feel they can call attention to it. And that creates a lot of suffering.”

Leave a Comment

Please enter your name.
Please enter a comment.

  • It’s hell to live with the HERPES virus, I lost almost almost everything that made me a complete human and also suffer rejection and pains, My life was drastically going down the drain till I found useful information online that directed me to this website ‘herpesredemption.com’ where I read useful information about the virus and also contacted the email provided and to cut the story short, I was given instructions which I followed and the remedy was given to me, I used it and got healed.

  • Hello,
    I am so confused about all of this. Ive read many things saying that IgM tests are unreliable. I had a positive blood result for HSV2 but when they did a culture swab it was negative.. so i really dont know what to think.

  • Hello Everyone,
    I was tested for Hsv1 &2 1/29/19 and the nurse called me from a walk in clinic and stated I was negative for Hsv1 but I’m not negative nor positive for hsv2 because the index numbers were equivocalso I would need to come in to get another test done? How many people has this happened to?

  • I was diagnosed of herpes 6 years ago, the doctor said there are no possible cure for the virus. But i never gave up hope of getting cured. i have been living with it taking acyclovir to prevent outbreaks. I have been doing everything possible to get cured, so i never stopped doing research about finding a cure, i came across testimonies of people getting cured by Dr. Okasi herbal medicine. I contacted him through his website: okasiherbalsolution. webs. com, we talked on phone and i discovered he was genuine. I gave it a try and got the medicine from him, took it has he has prescribed and i’m so happy to say i’m completely cured, i went back to my doctor to confirm it. It’s so amazing, a thing of joy. Dr Okasi herbs medicine is capable of curing HSV 1&2 completely. contact him today Email: okasiherbalsolution @ outlook. com..

  • Pls i tested positive to HSV2 with an index value of >1 I really want to know which index value indicates that ur HSV positive

  • Hello everybody, I just want to give this great testimony to the whole public about a great man who help me out in a serious illness. I have HSV-1 AND HSV-2 DISEASE for good 2 years now and I was almost going to the end of my life due to the illness. All I have in my mind is, let me just give up because life is not interesting for me any longer and i also pray that God should accept my soul when ever I’m gone luckily for me, my kid sister run to me that she found a doctor in the INTERNET who can cure HSV-1 AND HSV-2 DISEASE. She helped me out in everything, the man asked for my details so he can prepare a herbal medicine for me. After he was done consulting on my details he told me how my medicine will be prepare, after he was done preparing my medicine he sent me my medication and after using it for 7 days i later started noticing something different in my blood so I went for my HSV-1 AND HSV-2 DISEASE test and I was tested Negative, I’m so happy that I can say I’m not patient of HSV-1 AND HSV-2 anymore. If you have HSV-1 AND HSV-2 or any sickness,HIV/AID,HPV,CANCER,HEPATITS B DIABETITS ALS,PENIS ENLARGEMNT please for your safety, contact DR.HAZIM VIA email address (usmandrhazim@gmail.com) or whats APP number+2349058026857

  • When I was living with the virus HSV, I thought I was doomed, as so many persons force me to believe the no cure idea but that changed the moment I contactacted herpesredemption.com, My hope was brought back alive by the comforting words of the doc, they placed me on three weeks anti biotic body flush and at the end of it my subsequent test result came out negative and I now have a normal life free from disease, say no to HERPES, visit herpesredemption.com for help. say a big NO to dieases

  • I’m 22, I was diagnosed with HSV-2 about 5 months ago. I’ve been really trying to dig deep to find the information that I need because quite frankly, I feel beyond uneducated. I started out on Valtrex 1GM (once daily, twice for recurrences) due to having 3 outbreaks within the first months. I am on my 7th outbreak, just switched to Zovirax 400 MG- twice daily. But this most recent outbreak, with my best educated guess, has been lingering for close to 2-3 weeks now. I’m still not fully aware or my signs leading up to having an outbreak. As well as simply being able to tell if I am having one or not.. Which is scaring the sh** out of me. While surfing the internet I stumbled upon a testimony from someone with HSV-1 got cured through Herbal medication. I was more than willing to try it. I called the number that was written in the testimony, i explain to doctor fabien about my HSV-2 and I ordered the herbal medication, i used it for 2 weeks my health has change the meds worked without any trace of side effects. i’m so happy, thanks to dr.fabien for helping me out.

    • No idea if this will be of any use to you, but I heard that research shows if you treat a sore with fluoride you’ll never get one in that same spot again. No idea of the accuracy of this claim, but fluoride is cheap so thought I’d mention it.

  • Dealing with the in earthly experience of having been told about having HSV 2 is so devastating for me and have not shared it with anyone yet because it’s a horrible thought inside! I just fill like I ruined my life. But I’m holding on to hope that it’s wrong and I’m safe from it! I want a retest because I don’t want to believe it! I pray it’s inaccurate! The nurse that gave me the results was so calm about it like “ You don’t need to worry about it because it’s not as serious as u think” Everything else was clear until she got to the Herpes and she said that I tested positive I’m like Omg!!! No symptoms other thank a paranoid itch and but that’s about it

    • If you have no symptoms find out what your antibody level was on your positive test. If it was under 3.5 get a western blot. I tested positive multiple times on the standard test. Western blot says I’m negative.

    • Cause I was around 1.25 when it said I was positive. And a ladyfriend that went and got one that even brought it to my attention was lower then me but positive the first time and unequivocal the second but both from the same location. I had one done at planned Parenthood and then an actual Quest diagnostics and both came up positive but with the same exact number though I took one on one day and the other the immediate next day. This was back around the time this actual article was written.

  • I woke up one morning in early September and could feel small barely visible bumps in the lining of my mouth under my tongue. The next few days they were on my lips. The next day the bumps on my lips were gone but could still feel the ones under my tongue. I seen my doc at the end of October, showed him a pic of my lip and he said it looked like a viral HSV. Without testing, he put me on the Valacylovir for a week but the bumps under my tongue were still there. Since he said it looked like a viral HSV I asked for the blood test. Results came back positive 3.28 index for the HSV 2 IgG test. He started me back on the meds but I have never had any other symptoms or nothing in the genital area. The bumps aren’t sores, they dont hurt, and they dont itch and I dont think that they are connected to my positive test results and they are still under my tongue. I’m just confused because I feel like I’m taking the pills for nothing since I haven’t had any of the typical herpes symptoms/outbreaks that I’ve been reading about. Just wondering if I should retest and get a second opinion and should I stop taking the pills…

    • A western blot is the only way to know for sure. I thought I was positive for 4 months. Turns out I’m not. Same levels as you.

    • Hello Anon. So when I go to my doctor, should I ask him for a re-test with the western blot test or should I go to a new doc and ask? I kinda feel like he’s gonna try to talk me out of it.

    • Cause I was around 1.25 when it said I was positive. And a ladyfriend that went and got one that even brought it to my attention was lower then me but positive the first time and unequivocal the second but both from the same location. I had one done at planned Parenthood and then an actual Quest diagnostics and both came up positive but with the same exact number though I took one on one day and the other the immediate next day. This was back around the time this actual article was written.

Sign up for our Daily Recap newsletter

A roundup of STAT’s top stories of the day in science and medicine

Privacy Policy