LOS ANGELES — Even before the pandemic, burnout, anxiety, and disillusionment were already endemic in the medical community. Then came the hit-or-miss response to Covid-19, which has left U.S. health workers exposed to infection — and ill-prepared to care for thousands of vulnerable patients.
Now, there’s simmering anger, and a deep sense of betrayal among health professionals who say they feel forsaken by their government.
STAT interviewed more than a dozen physicians and scientists around the country, and one after another, they leveled strikingly similar critiques at both the federal and local levels: That the Trump administration neglected scientists and public health experts and downplayed the severity of the disease, helping stoke a spread of misinformation. That many state leaders, toeing party lines, were too paralyzed to act in a timely fashion. And that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, once a venerable institution, bungled a critical component of pandemic control — diagnostic testing.
“I’m livid. This is all being mismanaged, and we’re being put at risk unnecessarily,” said Barry Schapiro, an orthopedic surgeon practicing in Palm Beach, Fla. “We had ample time to prepare. It didn’t have to be like this.”
Eric Topol, a cardiologist and director of the Scripps Research Translational Institute in San Diego, said, “The American public doesn’t know that a large portion of this catastrophe was preventable, if not for the sinful incompetence of our leaders. It didn’t have to be like this.”
Most physicians would agree to speak to STAT only on the condition of anonymity, citing fears that they’d face retaliation from their health systems — who are chastising, or even firing, desperately needed health workers for speaking out.
“Many of us feel we’ve been put at risk by the ineptitude of leadership across the board,” said one critical care physician in Miami. “We saw a pandemic developing, but still couldn’t get our hands around it.”
Here in Los Angeles, a primary care doctor put it this way: “I alternate between anxiety attacks and rage over this … everything is shrouded in secrecy,” she said. “It’s an American shame.”
Some interviewed noted that their peers in health and science had sounded the alarm early, based on preliminary Covid-19 data from countries like China, Italy, and South Korea indicating that quick, decisive action was paramount. They said that public officials frittered away time in January to mobilize medical supplies, trace the disease’s spread, and potentially contain it within the U.S.
“What really stunned me, and disturbed me: Even though we had been warned by experts and were well-positioned to act, nobody paid attention,” an emergency physician in New York City, also speaking on the condition of anonymity, said. “We seem to have been caught completely with our pants down in the U.S.”
The first Covid-19 case was discovered stateside on Jan. 21 — the same day as South Korea. The prudent move, several doctors pointed out, would have been to immediately fast-track a rapid, reliable, scalable diagnostic test.
But instead of using a ready-made test developed by the World Health Organization, the CDC opted to create its own. The CDC test malfunctioned, leading to a series of delays. Nearly three months later, it’s still a fraught and time-consuming process to get a coronavirus test in most parts of the country.
“These tests are not that complicated, and aren’t that expensive,” the New York physician said. “It’s staggering that we failed so profoundly here.”
“I’m livid. This is all being mismanaged, and we’re being put at risk unnecessarily. … It didn’t have to be like this.”
Barry Schapiro, Florida orthopedic surgeon
In the months before testing began to pick up steam, the disease spread unchecked in U.S. hospitals. Patients with upper respiratory symptoms or pneumonia were admitted to the hospital — “and they were just giving massive viral loads to nurses, doctors, respiratory therapists, paramedics,” Topol said.
“This situation has not only put the entire American population at risk of getting sick and dying — it’s endangered our health care force,” he said.
Hospitals across the country have been rapidly running out of personal protective equipment — and many still aren’t getting supplies fast enough from state and federal governments.
“I’ve been scrambling for [personal protective equipment] for the past three weeks,” the Los Angeles primary care doctor told STAT. “I don’t fault my employer for this. This is a failure of investment in pandemic planning.”
Masks, gloves, and gowns are still in dangerously low supply, and many medical professionals have resorted to buying gear on their own dime — or making it. In just two large Michigan health care systems, 2,200 employees have tested positive for the virulent disease. More than 100 doctors and nurses have died around the world — including three young resident physicians in the U.S.
The lack of preparation “has crippled us clinically,” the New York emergency physician said.
“So many common sense things would have changed the course of this,” he said. “It’s very baffling. And infuriating.”
Many physicians placed much of the blame directly on Trump.
His rhetoric has hampered containment efforts, said Terry Adirim, a trained pediatric emergency physician who previously worked as a senior Department of Defense and Homeland Security official.
“There’s still no real leadership,” said Adirim, who now helps lead clinical care at Florida Atlantic University College of Medicine. “On a national scale, who on earth is in charge of handling this pandemic? I’m flummoxed.”
As researchers were sounding alarm bells in February, the president called the novel coronavirus “a hoax,” claiming that Democrats were politicizing the pandemic to discredit his presidency. That transitioned into falsehoods about the country’s response to the virus — including exaggerating the number of Covid-19 tests the country had conducted.
“There’s a larger cognitive failure here that’s profound,” the New York ER doctor said in reference to the president.
Adirim worked with the federal government during the 2009 swine flu outbreak — and noted that there was far more communication between agencies than she’s seeing today. She believes that’s a result of the administration’s attitudes toward public health.
“There’s an unwillingness for the current administration to cede leadership to a competent individual,” Topol said.
The lack of faster action comes despite early warnings from advisors like Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases, who have advocated that aggressive steps be taken. Peter Navarro, Trump’s trade adviser, warned the president in late January that the Covid-19 crisis could cost the U.S. trillions of dollars — and infect millions of Americans.
“Many physicians in our department are strong Republicans — they love Trump’s business mind and policy,” said a resident emergency physician in the metro Detroit area. “But no one thinks he is handling this crisis appropriately.”
While the pandemic response has largely been relegated to local and state legislators, many interviewed complained about the lack of action on that level. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, for instance, only imposed a shelter-in-place directive on April 1 — several weeks behind states like California, Ohio, and New York.
“But our governor exempted churches, and the federal government said gun stores are essential,” said Adirim, who lives in Boca Raton, Fla. “So that’s just playing politics with the pandemic. And this cannot be made political. This is public health.”
Schapiro, the orthopedic surgeon from nearby Palm Beach, agreed.
“Either [politicians] don’t believe science, or they’re listening to lobbyists who are more interested in financial blowback than anything else,” Schapiro said. “I don’t know why they dropped the ball — except they were playing politics because the economy was at risk.”
Meanwhile, Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp claimed that, until last week, he had no idea that the novel coronavirus was airborne.
“It puzzled me why he wouldn’t know this was airborne, when the CDC is about 15 minutes away from him,” said Kevin Kathrotia, a neonatal specialist who is based in North Carolina and practices in Georgia and Texas.
Although hospital leadership publicly adheres to CDC directives, emergency and critical care physicians said they look elsewhere for information on treating Covid-19.
Privately, one resident emergency physician in the metro Detroit area and his colleagues seek out guidelines from the World Health Organization, and scour medical literature to develop their own best practices in treating the virus.
“As an ER community, we’re cobbling all these resources together, and make our own decisions,” he said.
Kathrotia agreed, saying that the agency’s directives are changing constantly. For instance, it initially advised against the public wearing masks. Now, the CDC has suggested that every person wears a mask when they’re not home.
“I think there’s a lot of mistrust with CDC guidelines, because they seem to be pretty reactionary,” Kathrotia said.
Those interviewed expressed concern about Trump’s penchant for weighing in on particular treatments. On March 21, he praised the combination of the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine along with azithromycin, an antibiotic — saying they “have a real chance to be one of the biggest game changers in the history of medicine.”
While scores of scientists, including NIAID director Fauci, have warned that making these claims is premature, the Detroit area physician and his colleagues have been inundated with requests for them.
“The comments Trump is making about drugs — that’s just wrong,” the metro Detroit resident physician said. “It’s really upsetting, and not the sort of information we should be getting from the government.”
Among the physicians, there’s a growing fear that they’ll face repercussions if they speak out. Ming Lin, a doctor in Washington state, was fired after publicly speaking about supply shortages at his hospital. Other workers have been told they’ll lose their jobs if they don’t treat coronavirus patients. So doctors are staying anonymous.
“The thought of being fired right now, when my patients need me the most, is even more terrifying than the idea of potentially getting ill from Covid-19,” the Los Angeles primary care physician said.
Those on the frontlines are also worried about their own health.
Nisha Mehta, a radiologist with the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, launched an online petition on Change.org aimed at lawmakers — pushing for stronger protections for the health care workforce. The “Covid-19 Pandemic Physician Protection Act,” which has been sent to several members of Congress, calls for adequate personal protective equipment, tax credits for the health care workforce, and mental health coverage for physicians. More than 110,000 people have signed the petition.
“If the very people who have to pull us through the crisis are burnt, demoralized, and angry — where do we go for help, as a society?” said a Boston psychiatrist, speaking on the condition of anonymity. “We have to protect our protectors.”
But when the pandemic has abated, and life has attained some level of normalcy, there needs to be a “reckoning” at the end of all of this, in which there’s an inquiry into what went wrong, several of the physicians said.
“My fear is that this will all get whitewashed — where we’ll look back and say that everyone rallied and was heroic,” the New York City physician said. “Voices of reason and science were shouting the truth — but were allowed to be ignored, and thousands died because of it. This is a crucial lesson for history.”
Very disappointing politicized article disguised as journalism. These anonymous quoted physicians are angry with “Trump” but not at China, not at NYC officials who encouraged social gatherings, not at the shameful lack of PPE available thoughout the country, not at the outsourcing of pharmaceuticals and PPE manufacturing. I did not need anything “Trump” said or did not say to know this train was bearing down on us and we were not prepared. Come on, let’s work together to do better next time.
This article is ridiculously one sided. Full of inaccuracies(but some truth). ASA should really fact-check before giving hit piece a platform.
Very slanted article with interviews of people with professional titles who are blaming the government instead of the hospitals that were unprepared.
I think Dr. Fauci is one of the most respected docs in the US, if not the word. He and Mr. Navarro were at odds in regards to Chinese travel bans in January. More importantly Dr. Fauci was quoted by USA Today in mid February as saying that the risk of a Covid19 outbreak was “miniscule.” My point: a lot of very, very smart folks missed this – far smarter than Mr. Trump. But that said, just like FDR’s screw up at Pearl Harbor, this is not the time to blame. This is “all hands on deck” … a once in a century catastrophe. There will be plenty of time for the autopsy and the blame game later; and a verdict on Mr. Trump as well … in November. Now we, as well as the nation, are literally in a fight for our lives as well as our patient’s.
Regarding prior comment, while angry at situation, my desire is not to assign blame but for an objective “lessons learned” documenting mistakes and areas for improvement for each group and means to correct them, as we’ve done for decades in QA/root cause analyses. NO one is performing as a “10”.
Beyond sadness for clinicians overwhelmed and in distress without sufficient PPE, my frustration is that extensive efforts made by last administration to document mistakes and lessons learned with clear prescription and solutions was completely ignored, many of same mistakes repeated with new ones based on political environment, e.g. election year, greater partisonship.
There will be many post-mortems, hopefully objective. Current need is still testing (we lag behind in PER CAPITA.) and qualified staffing yet Becker’s reports 80 HCOs downsizing staff.
Clinicians reported rampant “moral distress” BEFORE COVID-19 (MD suicide rates high). We have 30 M uninsured, many more under-insured unlike any other country facing this. Our citizens are more unhealthy, co-morbid, often isolated, compared to peers, with serious racial disparity, ageism and profiteering in our system. ALL of this is playing out under a microscope. I don’t think we’ll go back, but not sure where this will lead us.
Just another piece bashing government for what has been going on since well before. Who gutted supplies? Every nation in the world failed to restock because the last pandemic didn’t pan out. Every state made their own decisions on what they would replace, including ventilators. Many of those states didn’t replace and didn’t buy anything new. In the interest of making health care cheaper, NOT being prepared for pandemics is part of that. ICU beds in particular are expensive to maintain and require specialized staffing. If all the countries in the world had the number of ICU beds that we have, their death rates wouldn’t have been so terrible. And hospital administrations are also often to blame. When key people start saying you need to get more PPE, more N95s, more PAPRs and they refuse – well that isn’t the government’s fault.
Joy, you are correct. This is not the time to blame. We should recognized on the other hand that, for whatever reason, we have shortage in critical equipments. This puts patients and our lives at a greater risk.
Objectivity should be our goal. It is obvious that crucial delays contributed to the present situation. Let’s look beyond our little alley. Safety equipments may be available for some, but are not for many others. Ask your internist, ask other healthcare professionals, not involved in critical environments, but still dealing with the public. Ask the nurses, the pharmacists, ask the public. Are masks available in your hometown pharmacy? Alcohol, gloves, and are tests available? Let’s be honest, I agree that few doctors do not represent the entire healthcare, but my question is: where are our medical societies, why aren’t they speaking up? Either the problem does not exist, or, if it does, they are not helping. In Italy they had the 100th casualty among doctors with several thousands infected healthcare workers. Are we doing enough to avoid the same scenario?
What a BS hit piece. The Wuhan virus was covered up and misinformation spread by the CCP. President Trump acted swiftly once it became clear that the Chinese were lying. Educate yourself and get the facts. See:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3bXWGxhd7ic&t=513s
There is so much evidence that Trump did NOT act swiftly at any point, including now. And would you really rely on the Chinese government’s numbers anyway? The only thing he did was close off flights from China but not until long after it had been spreading in this country. He has refused to make any consistent efforts to get tests or medical supplies to where they are needed. After dealing with Covid (+) patients, I was only able to be tested myself by lying about symptoms. I’m not even sure if he could botch the federal response to this pandemic any more than he has. South Korea and we had our first cases at the same time and they are so much further ahead on containing the damage. Have you even watched any of his daily press conferences on the pandemic? He treats any question that isn’t prefaced with gushing praise as a personal attack on him and politically motivated. He then digresses into either irrelevant subjects or on unhelpful tangents. Are YOU taking or prescribing hydroxycholoquine for your patients? Do you care if he pardons the Tiger King? Fortunately, the American public is slowly coming to realize that he is totally unqualified to be in charge in a crisis and hopefully we will be rid of him after next January.
This article is atrocious!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So many inaccuracies!!!!!!!!!! Was this written by the DNC ? CA has become SO left wing. Am a native Californian, and I am glad that I left the state several years ago. Am still practicing Anesthesiology and yes, I am treating Covid 19 patients in the hospital where I work. We are not having these problems!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So where’s the science in an interview consisting of a “few more than a dozen” individuals? And maybe these health care workers should look at their own lack of preparation.Our hospital already had protocols in place, for massive trauma and other catastrophies, but much of the response is the same, and stockpiles of masks and gowns. ‘LEAN’ went out in the last decade.
Everyone is stressed and overworked, its easy to find a scapegoat. Often our scapegoat happens to belong to the other politicsl party.
If you need to blame someone, blame China (who knew about the virus for 2-3 months) and the WHO who told the world
it was not communicable human to human (becauseChina said so).The WHO never called it a pandemic until way late.Trump closes the boarder for entry from China and the liberals call him a racist, because the WHO said it wasn’t necessary.
all the monday morning cornerbacks will point fingers; with every crisis we look back and see things we coiuld have done better; The stories will change in time to the story of thousands of heroic medical personal who risked their lives to save the human race. frankly I’d rather hear these stories than about a handful of whiners. We all have something we could whine about, but lets not miss the thousnds of stories of heroes.
Whiners? People on the front lines are not whiners. They’re doing their jobs heroically. You might want to reconsider.
Comments are closed.