When I graduated from medical school more years ago than I care to remember, my training as an intern and a resident followed an unrushed, traditional path. Medical students at the time were introduced to patients gradually, and we took our time engaging with the trying challenges that make up the bulk of a physician’s career.
This year, students graduating from the medical school where I am dean and from other schools are facing a very different time line: Due to the Covid-19 pandemic, many of them have been called upon to volunteer or work in hospitals before their time in medical school was over.
That’s not unprecedented. In 1918, some medical students were graduated early to help fight the raging Spanish flu. In 1952, medical students in Denmark helped provide polio patients with round-the-clock manual ventilation. In the 1980s, doctors in training were thrust into the burgeoning AIDS epidemic.
But none of these match the global shutdown we’re experiencing now, and the young men and women officially donning their white coats as new doctors will soon realize that the world they’re entering is one profoundly altered by the pandemic.
They will be changed by it, as will medicine.
As they work at the bedsides of those with Covid-19, new doctors will discover a skill too long ignored by most medical schools: empathy. From my days as a trainee until quite recently, medical education focused almost entirely on increasingly specific specialization. Medical students were encouraged and rewarded for how well they mastered their chosen field, not how kindly they spoke to the frightened person looking them in the eye, eager for a glimmer of good news.
This massive outbreak changes all that, making clear that no matter how great physicians’ technical skills are, they may not be considered healers until they’ve learned how to soothe and inspire, to comfort patients and family members alike (even when it’s compassionately delivering bad news), to deliver not only treatment but also hope. Working in hospitals packed with patients of all ages and demographics, and tending to those who, due to isolation, can’t be with their loved ones, will teach new doctors skills their older peers all too often had to pick up on their own.
As my students and others all across the country make their rounds, they will likely notice that while an infectious disease like Covid-19 afflicts people regardless of race or wealth or education, its impact varies widely based on socioeconomic status. Walking the hospital corridors, physicians in training will notice that patients who exist paycheck to paycheck, or who live in one of the many food deserts that blight even America’s wealthiest cities, are more likely to suffer from heart disease or diabetes and, as a result, are more likely to be harder hit by the virus. They will also notice that many of these are people of color.
Such a realization can and must change everything about the way medical students perceive their profession, as well as everything about the way future generations of physicians are trained. Social determinants, we now know — a person’s income, say, or ZIP code — have a tremendous impact on his or her well-being, which is why death and disease rates can vary wildly even among residents of the same city who live in different neighborhoods.
These data points should no longer be considered incidental, the sort of soft stuff a physician can easily ignore and something that once wasn’t taught in medical school. Instead, we should make it a point to ask questions about a patient’s socioeconomic condition as part of the intake process so we can better understand the fuller picture of her or his life and better help him or her recover.
Finally, beginning a career during a lethal and fast-spreading outbreak will likely do one more important thing to shape the mindsets of this year’s graduating medical students. The young men and women who gravitate to medicine as a profession often do so because they’re enamored of the scientific method and because they believe in using science to help heal the world. But watching a pandemic ravage the entire planet, leaving hundreds of thousands dead in its wake, is a good but terrible reminder that the scientific method is just that — a method, not blind faith — and that there are few more crucial and humbling moments in a doctor’s life than simply saying, “I don’t know.”
While I hope and believe that the brightest minds around the world will soon find treatments for people with Covid-19 and a vaccine to prevent it, I know that helping care for patients in the absence of a cure will teach students humility, an essential trait for all of us but especially for doctors, who are frequently called on to make life or death decisions.
As I watch my students rush into hospital wards well before the ordinary course of their training would have them do so, I find myself inspired not only by their dedication and eagerness to help but also by the knowledge that, as difficult as their path may be, they will emerge from it as better healers, for the benefit of us all.
Lawrence G. Smith, M.D., is the founding dean of the Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell.
I sincerely hope that Deans of all Medical Schools have the same wisdom, educational insight, and respect for humility as a truly essential element in practising good medicine. Thank you, Dean Lawrence Smith. The learning curve for the soon-to-be physicians is steep, getting their hands wet early – with a pandemic new viral disease that causes so many complications and inflicts so much loneliness. I thank them all for their participation in treating, learning, caring and growing.
Please change the title of your article. Medical students become physicians, which is a licensed profession. Using the word “doctors” in this headline is an inappropriate use of the degree designator that many nonphyscians have earned.
No just better Doctors but Humanitarian Doctors!
The Covid-19 pandemic will offer young physicians more than the opportunity to learn how to be better healers. Given the effects of this disease on so many organ systems, treating Covid-19 will sharpen diagnostic and therapeutic knowledge that will be invaluable for a lifetime practicing medicine. William Osler used to say “He who knows syphilis knows medicine.” Covid-19 is the 21st century syphilis.
Agree. The sooner medical students are involved in bedside medical care the better. The evolution to becoming a licensed MD is more rapid and meaningful when the initiates are right in the trenches. Oversight/ supervision is important but medical education is best when the student is not a passive bystander.
Thank you for this thoughtful article. I wish it is widely read and circulated. Doctors and we all need humility and compassion. Covid-19 has exposed our injustices and the incompetence of our political and business leaders across the world.
Comments are closed.