Skip to Main Content

In 2017, Karen Porter mentioned something unusual at a routine neurology appointment: Everything she saw appeared to be vibrating.

The 57-year-old U.K. resident has chronic migraines, and over the past few years had become increasingly sensitive to light; her house was almost completely blacked out, except for a dim camping light. In low light, she’d noticed the startling change in her vision. 

When Porter’s neurologist, Manjit Matharu of the National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery in London, examined her eyes, he noticed the pupils appeared to jump around uncontrollably, a condition called nystagmus. Matharu, whose expertise is primarily in treating migraines, referred her to Diego Kaski, another neurologist at the hospital who studies eye movement disorders.


As detailed in a new case report published Monday in the Annals of Internal Medicine, Kaski eventually diagnosed Porter with a condition almost entirely confined to history: miners’ nystagmus. Without any standard course of treatment to rely on, Kaski and his colleagues pursued a novel strategy of gradual light re-exposure that eased Porter’s nystagmus and light sensitivity. The case, they say, also demonstrates the principle of neuroplasticity, which enables the brain to continuously adapt to environmental changes.

Chronic migraines affect over 4 million adults worldwide, and those with the condition can be sensitive to and avoid light even when they don’t have a migraine. But Porter’s case was unique — she had avoided all light for 18 months. When he first met her, Kaski said she wore three blindfolds and a hat to block out all light from above, and couldn’t tolerate removing them so Kaski could examine her eyes in the bright clinic room. When Kaski examined her eyes in the dark, he immediately noticed the nystagmus. Early on, he thought it was related to her visual deprivation. 


“I suspected it when I first met her,” said Kaski, the lead author of the case report and an associate professor at the University College London Institute of Neurology. Nystagmus is common in people who are blind, and Kaski said Porter’s avoidance of light was striking. But Porter’s eyesight was still perfectly fine in low light. Some sighted people have the condition from birth, but in that case the brain adjusts to it, making vision appear normal. Brain scans also confirmed that Porter hadn’t had a recent stroke, another potential cause. 

Kaski said it took him several weeks to piece together what was happening. He took a deep dive into the medical literature, from controversial studies on cats who had their eyelids sewn shut to reports on people who’d been imprisoned in dark places. Finally, he found something. 

“I came across miners’ nystagmus in a very old textbook,” he said. In the late 1800s, British coal miners would sometimes develop nystagmus, after working underground for several years. The eye condition, along with a collection of other symptoms such as headaches and breathlessness, became known as miners’ nystagmus. But doctors at the time couldn’t figure out what could be causing it, and concluded that it must be psychological disorder — the miners must be controlling the eye movements themselves. 

Today, Kaski said, it’s thought that the nystagmus was a direct consequence of the extreme low light and visual deprivation. Mines in the 19th century were often very dimly illuminated by candlelight or gas lamps, and coal itself reflects almost no light. It makes sense that nystagmus might occur as the result of this extremely low light for the same reason it occurs in blind people, said Joseph Rizzo, a neuro-ophthalmologist at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear hospital and a professor of neuro-ophthalmology at Harvard Medical School. He said that typically, the brain develops a sort of coordinate system based on visual input so both eyes can focus on a single point, which allows for the best vision possible. But if there’s no visual input, your brain loses track of that system.

“If you lose those coordinates, the eyes get lost, basically,” said Rizzo, who was not involved in the case study. Kaski described nystagmus as a failure of the brain to inhibit the motion of the eyes, a process which relies on visual input. Unable to focus on anything, the eyes will essentially go on trying, moving rapidly back and forth in vain. 

Though Porter’s nystagmus seemed to match this centuries-old malady, Kaski said the historical insight did not give him any idea of how to treat her condition. Although she’d started avoiding light to control her migraines, Kaski said it was different medication that ended up helping her migraines the most. Light exposure did not actually seem to trigger her migraines, Kaski said, although it’s possible they could have lessened their severity, especially at first. If Porter were able to tolerate light again, Kaski reasoned, maybe her nystagmus would also resolve.

So Kaski and his colleagues devised a system to slowly reintroduce Porter to light. He had an electrician come to her and her partner’s home and install dimmer switches, and had them buy a lux monitor to measure the level of light. Week by week, Porter’s husband, Tony, would help her increase the light exposure in their home, and after a few weeks, Porter noticed that things “vibrated” less in her vision, and she could tolerate a small amount of light exposure for most of the day. A video included with the case report and displayed below shows the nystagmus greatly reduced after three months, and after eight months, it was entirely gone. 

Closeup video of Karen Porter’s eye movements near the beginning of her treatment in May 2017, in August 2017, and at the end of her treatment in January 2018. The video captures her eye movements with and without her focusing on a fixed point ahead. Diego Kaski

Porter was able to tolerate 50 lux for 12 hours a day after 13 weeks, which Kaski said is roughly equivalent to standing in the middle of a fairly large, otherwise unlit room with natural light coming in from through a few windows. That would still be relatively dim for most people. 

“Bright sunshine is very different to that,” Kaski said, with a light level of around 10,000 lux. But after eight months, he said Porter was finally able to come to the hospital without any blindfolds, and could be examined in a normal clinic room with the lights on. 

Rizzo noted how the case demonstrates the principle of neuroplasticity. Like a room where only certain people are engaged in conversation, the brain “has its favorite partners, where information is shared routinely,” Rizzo said. In response to any change, whether it is prolonged darkness, a brain injury, or a stroke, some of those conversations get interrupted. Neuroplasticity is when the brain adapts to a change and reconfigures itself, like new people in the room beginning to converse. Even the fact that the visual deprivation could cause miners’ nystagmus demonstrates how much one’s environment can change their brain, but even more remarkably, Kaski was able to find a relatively simple way to reverse the condition, which he feared might be permanent. 

“If you give the brain the right information, it can figure out how to do its job again,” said Rizzo. 

Porter still has chronic migraines, and, due to their current severity, was unable to talk with STAT directly about her health. In an email to STAT, her husband wrote that despite Karen being able to tolerate an increased amount of light in their home, the windows are still blacked out, as is the back of their car. He wrote that Karen is still largely housebound, leaving home only for doctor’s appointments. But they are hopeful that one day things could be different for Karen. 

“We continue to work towards her recovery,” Tony wrote. 

  • The migraine condition is often due to electrolyte imbalance and is treatable. Please share this information with anyone who is suffering. The main thing is a strictly low carb diet and more salt. See Stanton Migraine Protocol, for more information. Stanton’s reasonings are not perfect, but the protocol is solid and has cured many.

  • It’s called Chronic Migraine, not “migraines” …it’s a very common misconception but language is important. For example, people live with epilepsy. And they have seizures, they don’t have “epilepsys.” Migraine is a neurological condition in which you have migraine attacks. If you look at any of the major foundation such as the American migraine foundation they use the word migraine. Not migraines.

  • When I started reading this, my first thoughts were, maybe it was the amazing human brain’s way of trying to compensate for the lack of visual simulation… And upon reading further, I was pretty surprised when the doctor said he found something from the times of old that presented itself in miners! It made alot of sense to me!
    Glad to know that this woman was able to find medication that helped her be able to control her migraines better and be able to tolerate light better and better. And that particular eye tracking /vibration resolved itself.
    Nobody deserves to have to live such a limited life because of that unfortunate condition…. Migraines are no joke,and this I know, from my own experiences!
    Awesome article!

  • In the field of machine vision, jittering/shifting an image randomly in this manner artificially increases the effective area of a photo-detecting sensor, increasing the number of photons that can be detected by the sensor. So, the jittering of a pupil in people who spend lots of time in a low-light environment could just be the brain’s adaptaion to artificially increase the pupil’s effective diameter in order to detect more photons.

    Also, jittering of a image sensor in this way improves the brain’s detection of contrast in the task of low-light edge detection by sensing which cells in the retina flip back and forth between “light” and “dark”.

  • While this is quite an interesting display of neuro plasticity, the final paragraphs are disturbing. Why would they continue the very conditions (blackout windows) that caused the condition in the first place? This doesn’t make sense- something is very off here. And the fact that the patient was not able to respond with an update for herself is most disturbing.

  • I think patients with certain types of dementia can still experience neuroplasticity which can mean even as their dementia appears to be increasing, certain parts of the brain remain vital and intact. I think I witnessed it first hand with my Mother because she remained in her home with me as her full time live-in caregiver. I think nobody wants to test or talk about this because it means dementia is not necessarily a linear downward spiral.

Comments are closed.