Contribute Try STAT+ Today

MUMBAI — Working hard to keep her composure, Lavanya Sharma tweeted a short video on April 25. “Please please please help,” the teenage girl from New Delhi’s Uttam Nagar neighborhood wrote atop her post as her mother lay gasping for breath and her oximeter blinked a dangerously low reading of 52/100.

Sharma’s frantic calls for help didn’t get an official response until the next day, when an ambulance finally arrived to take her mother to the hospital.

This harrowing tale highlights the plight of millions of Indians who are being pushed to the brink by the country’s ferocious second wave of the pandemic.

advertisement

I know what Sharma is going through, having seen family members and friends laid low, and even killed, by Covid-19. A neighbor, in his 60s, died while on a ventilator. A political leader who helped me get my first home in Mumbai in 1996 died two days ago from a cardiac arrest that occurred as he was getting treated for Covid-19. Everyone in my sister’s family was sickened by the infection at the same time, but they appear to have recovered. My in-law’s family had it tougher, with two sons ages 28 and 31 needing oxygen in intensive care units for several days. Others, desperately needing treatment, were unable to get into hospitals.

In cities big and small, hospitals are too full to accept new patients and diagnostic centers take up to three days or more to do chest scans of those who might have Covid-19. Doctors and hospital staff are completely exhausted.

advertisement

Social media is flooded with passionate pleas for oxygen cylinders and concentrators. WhatsApp groups are filled with messages as friends and families scramble to access oxygen, remdesivir, tocilizumab, steroids, and other therapies. In a country where drug regulatory oversight is suspect, indiscriminate sale of fake drugs is a huge problem.

As someone who has covered the pharmaceutical and health care industries for more than two decades, I get calls for help into the wee hours of the night from family members, friends, and even acquaintances. Fake therapies are something I constantly worry about as I try to use my contacts to help people looking for hospital beds, medicines, or oxygen cylinders. Sometimes I’ve been able to help, but the calls are so many and the problems so big that often I cannot.

The merciless spread of Covid-19 is driving families to extreme limits. People with the means to do so are shelling out on the black market as much as 10 times the cost of a single vial of remdesivir. Others, many of whom are being pushed to bankruptcy, resign themselves to destiny.

Television stations routinely dish out painful stories of families who lost loved ones. “I have money, I have everything but I could not save my sister,” says a young person who cried inconsolably in a TV news report.

Hospitals don’t have enough beds for those seeking help, and even if they do, the shortage of oxygen is an agonizing death sentence for patients who can’t get access to it. Video clips are making the rounds showing people dying even as they are hurriedly wheeled on stretchers into hospitals.

Ambulances are being crammed with the dead — as many as 20 bodies at a time — on their way to crematoria and burial grounds. Funeral pyres glowing 24/7 are a constant reminder of the staggering death toll.

If there is an apocalypse, this has to be one.

Covid-19 is spreading at a terrifying pace, now averaging 350,000 new infections and nearly 3,000 deaths a day. As I write this, the official number of deaths is nearly 198,000.

Public health experts, however, suggest that the number of deaths could be several times higher, and possibly in the millions. They point to the glaring mismatch in deaths attributed to Covid-19 in government files and the actual number of deaths registered at crematoria and burial grounds.

The seething rage at the failure of the government and its precipitous public health catastrophe is giving way to an uneasy sense of desolation and helplessness.

India’s early success in nearly flattening the Covid-19 curve in 2020 may be the cause of the current calamity. Despite a rickety and funding-starved health care infrastructure, the country’s ability to manage the first wave of Covid-19 looked laudable as the United States, Canada, and countries in Europe reeled under second and third waves of the pandemic. Then things went awry. The turnaround raised false hopes that the virus had run out of steam in India and the country would be spared a second wave.

Virologists, modeling experts, and prominent epidemiologists appeared on TV shows to suggest that herd immunity may have kicked in, with testing in some cities showing the existence of anti-Covid antibodies in up to half of communities. Some professed that Indians have stronger-than-average immune systems, or they may be spared from Covid-19 by cross protection from other infectious diseases. A few invoked evolutionary biology and said the virus will not kill all its hosts and endanger its own existence.

Then India’s hyper-nationalism took over. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and senior leaders from his Bharatiya Janata Party, who thrive on overwhelming popularity, took no time to claim victory in the fight against the virus. Election rallies attracted soaring crowds. As Modi and Amit Shah, the two top leaders, brazenly took off their masks during their incessant campaigns, those in the crowds followed and dropped theirs.

Further fueling new cases was Kumbh Mela, a gargantuan confluence of Hindu pilgrims who gathered for a holy dip in the Ganges River. As many as 2.5 million people took part, with scant attention to Covid-19 safety protocols. By the time an avalanche of criticism cut short the festival, the virus had infected thousands of pilgrims, who took it home to their neighborhoods and villages.

Efforts to crank up a badly hobbled economy also added to the spread. Business and manufacturing activities began reopening in May 2020 as ministers projected a V-shaped economic recovery while scientific messaging to keep wearing masks and follow social distancing took a beating. Masks, which had become part of public life in India for most part of 2020, gradually disappeared from faces.

As countries issue advisories suspending flight operations to and from India, the country’s dominance as a global vaccines player is in question. In January 2021, the Indian government authorized two vaccines for emergency use against Covid-19 and committed to help a host of countries vaccinate their residents. The pandemic’s second wave has dealt those plans a hard blow.

The Modi administration has expanded the scope of vaccination, now making the jabs available to anyone over age 18. While this is the right move, it has led to a shortfall of vaccines and slowed the pace of the vaccination drive. While vaccines are seen as the most effective intervention to cut the spread of the virus, there are now serious doubts on how efficiently can India roll out its program.

In 2002, India unveiled “Incredible India,” a high-octane advertising campaign aimed at drawing international tourists to the country of contrasts, cultures, palaces, and forests. Though the campaign remains, it is now overshadowed by the putrid smoke pouring from funeral pyres, the gasps for breath of those afflicted with Covid-19, and the cries of the millions of family members and friends who have lost loved ones to a pandemic wave that could have been prevented.

Unless we get out of this soon, I fear that we will be left with “Incompetent India” — or worse.

Vikas Dandekar is a senior pharmaceutical and health care journalist with ET Prime, an India-based website for analytical and investigative business stories.

  • India had a 1.3B population, so of course they will have a lot of cases and dead. But if you combined US and Brazil that is not even half of Indian population, you will see that US and Brazil have more cases and deaths, with the deaths under reported.

    Everyone is dealing with the covid19, many poorer countries than India had to take loan to buy vaccines and can’t even get access to the Pfizer and Moderns vaccine.

    Why does India feel that it is US and the world obligations to help them when the hoarded antibiotics and ban its export back then. The picture becomes more dramatic because they are burning the bodies. But the same scenario has happened in the US and Brazil expect these countries does not do public cremation so it is less dramatic. Everybody needs resources, but India is the only country that seems to feel US owed them something.

    Time and again, Indian demands something from US as if US owes them something. Look at the H1b Visa, India is the biggest beneficiary, when Trump reformed it, only India complain.

    Deal with it. I currently know someone in another country who have covid19 but cannot find and open bed in hospitals. Other countries have the same scenario, so lets us not make as if India is the only country in the midst of nightmares.

    Having said this, I do with sympathize with anyone sick but cannot find any hospital beds to take them in. Such situation should have been anticipated by any government since it been more than a year since since SARS was unleashed to the world.

    The same story about not having enough hospital bed had been repeated in many countries around the world. Italy was put in a situation where it had to decide who to save and who to turn away.

  • I appreciate the news on India for it’s own sake and for how it affects the vaccination production there, but we in the rest of the world need to know how well this new variant escapes natural immunity from infection with the first wave type, and the vaccines we are using.
    Perhaps this is not exactly the mission of Stat, but seems to me there must be a lot of readers who would like to know what is being done to get this information.

  • have China donate aid and money that is sorely needed since they are a humanitarian society

  • Excellent article! The good, the bad and the ugly portrayed accurately by this journalist. India bragged to the world very early that they were at the forefront of keeping Covid-19 in check. Our sincerest prayers go out to our brothers and sisters in India for an immediate breakthrough in ending this plague.

  • Absolutely fact is written and the culprits are government who had gone for election kumbh mela and person like Sadguru had gathered 2.5 lacs devotees on Mahashivratri. Not to talk about cricket matches holi and other festivals. No doubt equally we are also responsible who have attended all above functions. God also can’t do any thing. BJP failed this time. The whole world is SELFISH.

    • I can’t understand, Indian government is not poor. Why can’t the Indian government buy the Oxygen Concentrators. From what I am reading in the news, the Indian government seems to treat people like piece of garbage. There was a story of one migrant worker who cannot leave town on the first lockdown. He only eats one cup of rice a day. He goes around looking for food. The police beats him instead of helping him

      If you look at the Philippines which is another country in Asia. The government are giving poor people some stipends due to lockdown. They also have community pantries where people donate food and other people who needs food get the food.

      But if you look at India, it seems the government do not care if people die from hunger or other causes. Some people die while walking on the highway on the last lockdown. I also do no see the those with means helping the poor. Maybe because of India caste system, it train them to look down on people beneath them. India is the only country in the would with a caste system and the “untouchables”. Such inhuman system should not exist in the current century. People are all equal irregardless of status. All are destine to die from the day they are born.

      India tragedy is author by its government and its people.

      Germany is sending 3 oxygen generating plant to India.

    • India is rich. They have a space program, ICBMs and nuclear weapons. Nobody should need to donate in the first place. Especially not people outside of India. Why is their government not handling this?

    • Why Indian Prime Minister is maintaining a private fund. He do not believe his own government? PM Cares fund is biggest scandal in independent India. There is no audit on this fund. Modi is responsible for this corona crisis.

  • During the early stage of Covid, India hoarded N95 mask and critical medicine and ban its export. Now western countries are hoarding vaccine.

    The world should learn that to combat the covid19, the world must come together and share resources. No country is safe unless all countries are safe.

  • No country should feel confident that they conquer the virus. For as long as one country has one outbreak, the SARS can always be imported in.

    What happened to India is probably partly due to Indian people returning to India from UK during the UK lockdown when cover was imploding to UK. Some have brought back the UK variant with them to India. Half of India variant is UK variant, according to the news.

Comments are closed.