In a closely watched case, a U.S. patent appeals board ruled that a Native American tribe cannot claim sovereign immunity in order to avoid a certain type of patent challenge. The decision is a blow to Allergan (AGN), which last fall transferred patent rights to one of its biggest-selling medicines to the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe in hopes of thwarting generic competition.

Procedurally, Allergan sought to avoid inter partes reviews, a type of patent challenge that has vexed drug makers since going into effect six years ago, because these are easier and faster to file than patent lawsuits. At the time it transferred patent rights to its Restasis eye treatment, which last year generated more than $1.4 billion in sales, Allergan was facing a conventional patent challenge in a federal court.

Unlock this article by subscribing to STAT Plus and enjoy your first 30 days free!


What is it?

STAT Plus is a premium subscription that delivers daily market-moving biopharma coverage and in-depth science reporting from a team with decades of industry experience.

What's included?

  • Authoritative biopharma coverage and analysis, interviews with industry pioneers, policy analysis, and first looks at cutting edge laboratories and early stage research
  • Subscriber-only networking events and panel discussions across the country
  • Monthly subscriber-only live chats with our reporters and experts in the field
  • Discounted tickets to industry events and early-bird access to industry reports

Leave a Comment

Please enter your name.
Please enter a comment.

  • This is the kind of corruption that is going to ultimately destroy America. I have to use Restasis because of Sjogren’s Syndrome, I have great insurance and pay for that insurance but Allergan now has made that impossible. The lawyers and Allergan will ultimately pay for this … as I am a recently retired history teacherwho is very good at research and am now lobbying for us common folk. We are a corrupt and greedy country. I hope all the other drug companies can sue so there is competition (as their patent did run out and they r trying to thread the fine needle . I plan to research the Canadian connection (which is most likely India) to get my meds. Disgraceful! Unethical! Immoral! and I thought America(Capitalism) is about competition. I am spreading this all over FB, Instagram and the politicians are paid off to essentially screw the constituents who voted for them. I ain’t givin’ up.

  • This is great news. It’s about time we stop Tribes that are using their Tribal Immunity as a sword instead of a shield…and in this case to scam the public and other businesses for their own gain and greed.

Sign up for our Daily Recap newsletter

A roundup of STAT’s top stories of the day in science and medicine

Privacy Policy